American Horror Story has had many shocking moments, but the latest episode has left some fans doubting its quality. A strange scene has sparked discussion online, with viewers expressing their disappointment in the show’s creative choices. This response began after the finale of season 13, which aired on October 29, 2026. In one odd part of the episode, Emma Roberts’ character, Madison, becomes pregnant and gives birth in less than a minute. Fans who have followed the series were surprised by this quick sequence, even for a show known for its unusual style.
The childbirth scene gained attention on X on November 2, attracting over 700,000 views. Many viewers questioned why the show would condense a whole pregnancy into such a short time. Reactions included criticism of the writing and general concerns about the show’s direction. Some users expressed strong negative opinions about the show, with one suggesting that the writing was lazy and that different characters could have been used instead of a cameo.
Comments about the childbirth scene were part of a larger discussion about the season’s lack of depth. Some viewers described season 13 as possibly the worst they had ever watched, while others echoed that sentiment, stating they could not think of a season they disliked more. There were also comments suggesting that the season lacked seriousness and felt like a joke.
The backlash has also focused on showrunner Ryan Murphy, with fans expressing their frustrations about his recent work. Some viewers criticized his productions, stating that they used to be great but have not been for a long time. This criticism indicates a belief among viewers that the franchise is not telling stories as well as it once did.
The finale of season 13 is reported to be the lowest-rated episode in the history of American Horror Story on IMDb, with a score of 2.4 out of 10. The season has not received good reviews either, currently holding a 60% critics’ score on Rotten Tomatoes, down from 77% for season 12. Despite the negative feedback, the show was renewed for a 14th season on October 20, 2026. Many fans are now questioning if the anthology series should continue, with some calling for the cancellation of season 14, describing it as a disappointment for fans.
The criticism of American Horror Story season 13 comes shortly after another project by Ryan Murphy, Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story, also faced backlash. This series focused on the famous double homicide case from 1892 in Fall River, Massachusetts, and was criticized for how it portrayed the historical events, raising questions about its accuracy and creativity.
Sources:
Source: Bored Panda, by Gabija Saveiskyte