A casting choice for the show 9-1-1: Nashville is facing renewed criticism. Hunter McVey, who plays Blue Bennings, has come under fire after fans learned about his unexpected past. This discussion picked up again on November 3, 2026, when a user on X shared information about McVey’s previous work and his unusual journey to acting. This post surprised many viewers, leading some to question why he was cast and to criticize co-creator Ryan Murphy. The revelation also revived earlier complaints about McVey’s acting, with some fans suggesting their doubts about his performance now had a clearer reason.
McVey joined the show in June 2025, just before the October debut of 9-1-1: Nashville, a spin-off from the original 9-1-1 series. At that time, he had no prior acting experience and was mainly known as a model. Additionally, he created content for a subscription-based platform for adults. The conversation about his past was reignited on November 3 when an X user pointed out his previous content, expressing surprise that Murphy would hire someone from that background for a family-friendly network like ABC.
Despite the criticism, McVey has talked about his background since he began working on the show. In a November 2025 interview with The Hollywood Reporter, he shared how his modeling and content creation led him to acting. He mentioned that the platform allowed him to share modeling photos and connect with followers while providing a source of income that didn’t require as much travel. McVey recalled receiving many messages from fans asking for content, and he recognized how this experience may have been beneficial for his acting career.
Some viewers were taken aback by McVey’s previous role as a creator for an adult platform, especially given ABC’s reputation for family-centered programming. This new information has led to renewed complaints about his performance on 9-1-1: Nashville, with several fans labeling him as one of the weaker actors on the show. Many have expressed disappointment with his acting skills, stating that it makes sense why he struggles in that area. Critics on platforms like Reddit have also been vocal, questioning the decision to cast someone with no acting history in a prime-time role.
Previously, McVey discussed his work history before becoming a television actor. He mentioned holding several jobs, such as selling insurance across numerous states, working in marketing for a CBD firm, and selling full-body CT scans at a hospital. While at the hospital, he began sharing content online, committing to daily posts for a year, which eventually allowed him to quit his hospital job. He started a clothing brand and a podcast and launched multiple businesses during that time.
What do you think about the casting choices in 9-1-1: Nashville?
Sources:
Source: Bored Panda, by Lei RV